求助 正方 广告引起过度消费 反方 广告不能引起过度消费

bourdon

要辩论 我组的辩题是advertising is not responsible for excessive consumption

请教高人 作为反方一辩 要说些什么 只要列出条目就可以，最好用英语（要说3到5分钟的内容）

江户川柯南

首先，这是华语辩论网，所以关于英语辩论的问题，尽管我们愿意讨论，但恐怕优先程度要靠后一些了。这一次，是因为我个人觉得您对辩题的理解恐怕有些偏差，所以提出我的看法，顺便也就谈一下我对这个辩题的理解。仅供您参考。

Sorry, perhaps your translation might mislead those people who are going to reply your topic.

In your topic, it is talking about if the advertising should take its responsibility of the excessive consumption, but not talking about who causes the excessive consumption.

Based on your topic, the excessive consumption is a certain circumstance. You don't have to argue about if it is true or not. You may accept that the excessive consumption is a truth.

Besides that, you also don't have to argue about if it is caused by advertisements or not. You may admit that the excessive consumption is caused by advertisements.

However, what's the most important, in my opinion, is that the advertising don't have to be blamed.

As all of us known, the most significant purpose of advertisements are encouraging people's buying. If there is some excessive consumption which we don't need, I think it is the fault of ourselves. It is us who can not control ourselves very well. We don't have any excuse to blame the advertisements.

Take the story of lawyers as an example. The job of them are defending for their client. If, I mean if, their clients who are real murders have been sent free without any punishment, it is not the fault of those lawyers, although it is because of the lawyer's defendence. I think we should blame the police who has not work hard on finding enough evidence.

So, coming back to this topic, even if there is any excessive consumptions, we shouldn't blame the advertisements, but should blame ourselves who don't pay enough attentions to control our willing of purchase.

Therefore, no matter if there is any excessive consumption, and no matter if the excessive consumption is caused by advertising or not, the advertising is not responsible for the excessive consumption. If we do don't like the excessive consumption, we should find out the problems on ourselves.

要辩论 我组的辩题是advertising is not responsible for excessive consumption

请教高人 作为正方一辩 要说些什么 只要列出条目就可以，最好用英语（要说3到5分钟的内容）